The Riddle of Organization: Power and Insurgency in Times of War
However, the nature, form, and strategy of such a “weapon” have been far from self-evident, sparking intense debates that remain central to critical theorists and activists today. Over the last decades, the question of organization has become a riddle. Should a revolutionary organization operate with the discipline and efficiency of a military vanguard, or should it, like an artistic vanguard, prefigure the future life of freedom and equality? Should it be guided by professionals or led by the masses themselves? Should it aim to seize central power through insurrection or gradually build hegemony within the state’s main apparatuses? Should it be hierarchical or democratic, centralized or reticular, vertical or horizontal?
The “question of organization” is particularly compelling today, as capital responds to its multiple crises by weaponizing war, genocide, and ecological disasters. Addressing both theoretical contributions and practical experiences of organizing, this seminar will explore the “question of organization” in its historical and contemporary dimensions. By engaging with classic debates, artistic contributions, and recent analyses of social movements, it seeks to illuminate different forms of organizing that remain vital in today’s struggles for liberation. We do not have solutions to offer, but we remain convinced that the problem of organization is one of the crucial issues we have to address today. Reading will include works by classical Marxist thinkers as well as Rodrigo Nunes, Kristin Ross, and others.